Unscrambling Myths About Eggs

Photo: istockphoto.com/Chris_Elwell
White or brown? Free range or organic? Which are the healthiest eggs for your family?

Birds of a feather

There is no nutritional difference between white and brown eggs. It all comes down to feathers. Hens with white feathers produce white eggs. Hens with brown feathers produce brown eggs. More exotic breeds such as the araucana or ameraucana produce blue eggs. Of course, when you start to dye your Easter eggs you'll want to use white eggs.

An egg is an egg is egg

Contrary to popular belief, brown eggs are not healthier than white eggs. And the colour of the yolk has nothing to do with an egg's nutritional value but rather everything to do with a hen's diet. The more carotene or vitamin A eaten by the hen the more yellow the yolk. But pale yolks are just as nutritious as dark ones.

One per day

Eggs have gotten a bad rap from the cholesterol crowd. But according to a study done at Harvard University, eating one egg per day does not increase the risk of heart disease or stroke. The Harvard study's team of nutritionists, epidemiologists and physicians tracked 115,000 men and women and measured their health against egg consumption. They concluded that healthy people can eat an egg a day without raising their cholesterol to harmful levels.

Not so free

When we hear "free-range" we imagine happy chickens clucking around the yard in the sunshine. But since it's not a legal industry term, free-range is essentially meaningless when describing eggs. To use the label, chickens must have access to the outdoor—but being in a crowded pen with an open door or being in a barn with a window qualifies as free-range. You can get around this by finding a trustworthy supplier that raises chickens locally and without cages.

Organic is better

Organic eggs are healthier since organically raised chicken are not given antibiotics (growth hormones for poultry are not legal in Canada). The new Canadian Organic Standard, which came into force in June 30, 2009, requires that organic livestock management aim "to utilize natural breeding methods, minimize stress, prevent disease, progressively eliminate the use of chemical allopathic veterinary drugs (including antibiotics), and maintain animal health and welfare."

Under this standard, chickens must have access to the outdoors including pastures. However, standards vary in direct proportion to the size of the farm. The larger the farm the more crowding there will be along with practices such as debeaking. The secret is to find a small local source (usually at the farmers' market or farm stand).

Egg trivia

  • There are now 200 breeds of chickens.
  • An average hen lays 300 to 325 eggs a year.
  • A hen starts laying eggs at 19 weeks of age.
  • A hen must eat four pounds of feed to make a dozen eggs.
  • Occasionally, a hen will produce double-yoked eggs throughout her egg-laying career.
  • As a hen grows older she produces larger eggs.
  • The mother hen turns over her egg about 50 times per day so the yolk won't stick to the sides of the shell

For more green news, tips, innovations and debate, served with a strong Canadian point of view, visit greenlivingonline.com

Comments

When I bought eggs I looked for the free range because I was under the impression that these chickens were able to roam freely outside (in a secure area) eating bugs and whatever else they like. I chose these eggs because after learning how the mass of chickens/egg production are treated, I felt I could help in a small way by purchasing the eggs of better treated chickens. Also the free range eggs, although a higher cost than regular eggs, were still less than organic and I have to watch my pennies. But now knowing that I might not be buying the eggs of happier chickens, I will be purchasing the organic.
My girl friend Emily has always tried to be very PC "politcally correct" about buying green and eating green literally. It was nice that some of her myths that I couldn't disprove you were able too! The fact that white eggs are just as good as brown and that free range can technically be caged animals with open aired windows? What a scam thank you for your research.
The comment about packaging is an issue that periodically irks me. Its not just eggs. Many other more environmentally responsible products are sold to major commercial outlets, but are not packaged with the same thought put into the end product.
P.S. I live in a big city in South Florida with a small backyard garden. :-)
I solved my dilemma with free-range/organic eggs - I purchased three hens. It pleases me to offer them a happy life and great food in exchange for eggs. They roam the backyard garden by day and sleep in a crate in the house. They are smarter than given credit for - they actually wait by the door to be let in at dusk. Their value is in the whole experience - not in the feed vs eggs ratio.
Interesting article. One point I wished they would cover is about the packaging of the eggs. Has anyone else noticed that regular eggs come in carboard cartons, while "organic" ones come in plastic!?!? My boyfriend and I found ourselves in a dilemma once in the store when we noticed this. We'd like to buy the organic ones because they're supposed to be healthier, but then you have to forsake the environment by buying plastic! If anyone can provide a reason why they do this, I'd love to know. Otherwise, we are really no further ahead by buying organic. You'd think they would have figured this out by now. I'd be interested if Green Living did another article to cover this, and other packaging dilemmas that hinder our choices instead of helping them.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Copyright © 2010 of Green Living Enterprises, a division of Key Publishers Company Ltd. All rights reserved.

Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. GREEN LIVING is a trade-mark of Key Publishers Company Ltd.