How to recycle your CFLs

Photo: iStockphoto.com/jml5571
Only an environmental choice if you dispose right.

Energy-saving compact fluorescent light bulbs (CFLs) have to be handled differently that incandescent bulbs. Like other fluorescent lamps, CFLs contain mercury, which can be dangerous to human health and the environment. They should be disposed of properly (so no throwing them into your garbage can).

Minimum mercury

Before you panic, the mercury in CFLs is a small amount (between 1 and 25 milligrams, according to Environment Canada or, on average, 5 milligrams) that has been sealed within glass tubing. And according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, this small amount doesn't pose any major health threat. To put it into perspective: An old-fashioned thermometer contains 500 milligrams and a manual thermostat up to 3,000 milligrams—about the equivalent of 100 to 600 CFL bulbs.

Concentrating power

When mercury enters terrestrial or aquatic ecosystems, it gets converted into a more toxic form, methyl mercury, by naturally occurring bacteria, and accumulates in the tissue of plants and animals. So it poses a threat to species that are higher up the food chain. Tuna fish, an ocean predator, is notorious for containing high levels of mercury. So much so that Health Canada recommends that pregnant women and children limit their intake of certain tuna fish species (see the primer “Making Informed Choices About Fish.”).

Why mercury

Mercury allows CFLs to be an efficient light source and have a longer life. One CFL light bulb can save 2000 times its own weight in greenhouse gas emissions. Unfortunately there is currently no substitute for mercury so it remains an irreplaceable element. Scientists and researchers are working on finding alternatives, but until then CFLs will continue to contain mercury.

How to recycle

Most CFL bulbs with the Energy Star logo have a two-year warranty. So if your CFL gives up the ghost before its expiration date, bring it back to the store and ask for a replacement. Once it's time to recycle your CFL, don't just throw it into your household garbage can where it may leak mercury into whatever landfill it find its way to. Instead follow these steps:

•    Place the CFL in a sealed plastic bag.

•    Check with your local Household Hazardous Waste (HHW) Collection Centre to find out if they accept CLFs for drop off. You can also check with your local municipality. If it's inconvenient to visit your HHW Centre, then simply add the CFL to your batteries and other chemical waste for pick up. Municipalities usually have spring and fall pick-up drives. A god starting point is Environment Canada list of regional and provincial recycling programs.

•    Home Depot Canada and RONA offer a national in-store CFL drop off programs.

•    Some IKEA stores offer take back programs of used CFLs.

•    In the United States: Check with Lamp Recycle, a website developed by the National Electrical Manufacturers Association, to find a recycler in your area. U.S. citizens can also contact Earth 911 to find a recycling facility near them

Broken CFL are dangerous

Like any product with mercury, a broken CFL should be handled with care. No one wants to be exposed to this toxic metal, even a small dose. If you break a CFL light bulb, here’s how to clean it up safely:

•    Open nearby windows for 15 minutes or more to release any vapours.

•    Use disposable rubber gloves. Don't pick up fragments with your bare hands.

•    Don't vacuum or use a broom to sweep up the fragments.

•    Use a stiff piece of paper or cardboard to carefully sweep the fragments. Place the paper and fragments into a sealed plastic bag.

•    Wipe the area clean with a damp paper towel and place that towel into the plastic bag along with the fragments.

•    Dispose of the broken CFL the same way you would used batteries or oils. Don't throw them into your household garbage.

Another option

If you're unhappy about the idea of CLFs, check out some of the new LED lights. They are even more energy efficient and last even longer than CFLs, and do not contain mercury.

Comments

I've had CFL's in my house since they hit the market & have never had a problem. Some of ours are well over 5 years old. They are also as bright as any other light within 30 seconds. I think the problem must be in your wiring. How old is it & is it up to code?
I've never had any luck with CFLs, regardless of brand. I think the longest a CFL has lasted (in a lamp that was used just about every day) was probably six months. And that doesn't count that long period beforehand where it starts to take five or ten minutes to "warm up" and actually become bright enough to see anything. I currently have CFLs in the kitchen and I hate them; I have to plan ahead every morning. Get up, turn on the kitchen light, leave and come back later because it takes several minutes just to get any light out of them! It's a petty complaint, I know, but it's pathetic that I should pay more money AND go through the trouble of disposal for such an overhyped product.
I think every manufacturer should start a recycling program on their terms, whatever you make, you take back and reuse! If you need to recycle solar lights, look here, all the components are reused: http://www.yoursolarlink.com/solar-lights-recycling
I've been using CFLs for years with good results. When I replace a bulb, I write the date on the white ceramic portion with black marker. Then, if it does go kaputz, I know if it's lasted it's promised lifespan or not. I tape my receipts ON the box they came in and store the box in my pantry closet where I keep the other spare bulbs. I have only returned a bulb once. It only lasted a couple of months. I returned it to the store with the remaining GOOD bulbs in the box and I got a full exchange.
I'm with one of the posters - that my CFL bulbs crap out shortly after a year. Certainly they never get the 2 years they advertise, not even close. Also in agreement is, who keeps those receipts?
I agree with you, I have spent more money to replace CFL bulbs than what I could possibly save in hydro for several years. So I don't see how they can possibly be classified as green when they have such a disposal problem. I like LED's but they are pricey, so check out the price of different size bulbs first. So I'm back to my original, sun light in summer and some warmth from incadesent bulbs in the winter and some LED's
Good article. I thought it brought up some points most people aren't aware of. However, it needed to be edited and run through spell check before posting. Sorry, but I found two spelling mistakes just in a quick run through...yikes.
I've about given up on CFLs. I don't know where they get their life figures from, but I've had CFLs everywhere in my house for 5 or 6 years now, and the bulbs - all of them - never last more than 2 years, even with light use. Most of them punked out at closer to a year. And who keeps the receipts for light bulbs? and if you did, how would you know which bulb went with which receipt? So the mfrs are safe in their guarantee, because unless you just have one CFL in the house it's unlikely that you will ever take them up on the refund. I'm really not a happy camper about these things - and I've got bulbs from all different mfrs, so it's not just one lousy company, it's all of them. I'll have to look into the LEDs, but I'll do it very slowly . . .
LED's available at Home Depot, I think. But crazy expensive for now.
Keep in mind, also, that we use our light bulbs sparingly in the summer when days are long, and in the winter when we use them the most they help to heat our homes. So, incandescents are not as wasteful as some would make them out to be. For those of us who heat with anything other than electricity, however, they do shift our heating demand ever so slightly away from the grid and such political hot potatoes as coal and nuclear, brownouts and blackouts.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Copyright © 2010 of Green Living Enterprises, a division of Key Publishers Company Ltd. All rights reserved.

Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. GREEN LIVING is a trade-mark of Key Publishers Company Ltd.