Shedding light on polluting candles

  • email to a friend
  • print this page
  • Bookmark and Share

Shedding light on polluting candles

Image: istockphoto.com

(Mar 21, 2008) The romantic allure of the scented aromatherapy candle has seduced many of us. But unless you’re lighting the right candle, you may actually be polluting the air in your home.

Toxic wax
The most common candles are made from paraffin wax, a cheap sludge waste product of the petroleum industry. When paraffin burns, benzene and toluene are released into the air, both known carcinogens. Burning paraffin also produces petrol-carbon soot, carbon particles that don’t fully burn but are incandescent, giving the flame its bright white/yellow colour. Unfortunately, this soot has the toxins found in diesel, which ends up as residue on walls, ceilings, fabrics and even in the ventilation system. Those pretty gel candles may be crystal clear but they too are toxic, made from petroleum-based wax or synthetic hydrocarbons. The Canadian and American Lung Association both caution against prolonged exposure to fragrances and soot for the very young, the elderly and those with respiratory diseases.

Lighting up lead
Even more dangerous are candles with metal-core wicks, favoured because they don’t fall over into the wax when lit. But metal wicks actually release lead into the atmosphere. Jerome O. Nriagu, Ph.D., a professor of environmental chemistry at the University of Michigan, measured the amount of lead released in 14 different brands of candles with metal-core wicks. He found that burning four metal-wick candles for only two hours resulted in enough airborne lead concentrations to pose a threat to human health, particularly to young children. While banned in Europe, the U.S. and Canada, lead is still widely used in Asia and South America, both major exporters of the aromatherapy candles sold in North American stores.
Hastens Canada


According to the National Candle Association (NCA) based in Washington, D.C., most aromatherapy candles rarely contain essential oils. Even if they do, the amounts can never be large enough to produce a true aromatherapy effect. Most U.S. and Canadian manufacturers label their candles for fire safety, but they are not obliged to disclose hazardous, toxic or carcinogenic compounds used as ingredients. It can be difficult to know what you are buying.

Safe candles
The healthiest candles by far are vegetable wax candles made from hydrogenated soy, palm and coconut oils. Soy wax candles have become popular since soy is both affordable and plentiful. This biodegradable wax burns clean and any residue can be washed away with warm water and soap.

Beeswax candles are the most natural candles of all. Since the wax is a by-product of honey, these candles give off a sweet scent and burn clean. Although more expensive than paraffin or soy, beeswax candles last up to three times longer. Pure beeswax candles have a golden to amber colour. There are some beeswax candles that are ivory coloured but these typically have less of a natural honey scent. Be wary of candles labelled blended beeswax since these will often contain paraffin; look instead for the 100 percent beeswax label.

Safety tips
Be sure to buy candles with paper, cotton or hemp wicks and avoid those with shiny metal wire inside. Trim all wicks to half a centimeter cm (1/4 inch) to help complete combustion and reduce soot build-up. Keep candles out of drafts since wind makes candles burn faster and puts more toxins into the air. Paraffin candles that are slow-burning (they often feel greasy to the touch) have even more additives and should be avoided altogether. Throw out any candles in jars that have soot rings around the lip of the jar, as this is often an indication of lead dust. For a true aromatherapy experience put a few drops of essential oil into a defuser or into some boiling water.

Anne Colvey is a freelance writer based in Quebec. She's upset about having to give up those raspberry scented candles she got at Christmas.


Tags: candles, Earth Hour, solar energy. Browse our full tag cloud.

9 Comments

posted Jan 2, 2008 - 10:30 pm by sharon
When buying soy candles how do we know that the soy used in the candles is not from the fields of big corporations? Isn't soy used as filler for alot of foods and not small farmer or earth friendly?
posted Mar 6, 2008 - 7:07 pm by Kristan
Do not believe every thing you read on the internet. What is the environmental impact on the soil/land of growing the soy? What energy has to be used to process the soy into a form that can be used for candles?

Paraffin may not be perfect but if higher grades of it are used (including the gel), the more they are "filtered", surely using up some of this petroleum industry by-product is better than it being pumped somewhere or disposed of in other ways? Unless people are going to give up their lives of big cars that burn lots of fuel, they are STILL supporting the petroleum industry and things like soy are created by intelligent people looking to make money off the greater population through propaganda and advertising that "they are so great".

The study quoted within this for the lead is very old and it would be hard to find much lead in ANY wicks with metal cores these days... certainly in countries like the US, Australia, probably even Europe.

Don't get me wrong, I actually like soy candles as a whole, but I think the scare-mongering that goes on with regards to other candles is highly inaccurate and confusing to the public.

Soot in any candle is normally an indication that the wrong size wick for the wax has been used or the wick is too long... so just because you see a candle with soot doesn't mean its going to kill you with cancer! I've seen soy candles soot too...!!

Hope this helps people understand the situation more fully....
posted Mar 27, 2008 - 6:04 pm by suzanne
I am glad to see another bit of information on health and candles circulated. I would have to challenge that the healthiest candles label would go to soy or veggie based wax as I have seen many of these pumped with fragrances and 'stuff' that are akin to their parrafin partners. I am a strong and avid lover and supporter of beeswax candles, specifically Pheylonian Beeswax Candles who are located in Ontario. There are no scents other than natures scent, the wicks are natural plant fibers that are chosen based on the diameter of the candle, they are steeped in tradition and lore of candlemaking and they are beautiful!!! They do take commitment and practise to burn correctly (more for your buck) and with the maximum health benefits of releasing negative ions into the air to clean dust, smells, airborn crap...it's worth it!!
I have sold many, many candles in my detailed retail history and personally are quite addicted to their ambience as well. I have yet to find any other candle that was as pure or that actually cleaned the air as these candle do.
I think veggie is the lesser of evils but I am not one to jump on the soy wagon- found a quote the other day that said 85%+ of soy produced in US is GMO. Can't say that makes environmental sense to me...
I'll just stay with my beeswax and thank the bee for another of their inspiring, healthy products!
posted Apr 3, 2008 - 7:47 pm by Andrea
Definitely all good points. It would be interesting to study the difference in impacts between different candle type. I personally breathe easier though when I don't burn a petroleum wax-based candle knowing that there are fewer chems burning into my home's air.

I recently found a candle made from vegetable oil from a company called Luminus (http://www.luminusonline.com/canada/index.asp). They have fragrance free candles as well as nice essential-oil scented ones.

I bought them as stocking stuffers for Christmas last year. Now if we could find something like this that was produced locally and packaged minimally, we may have a winner!

Or....we can all make our own: http://www.instructables.com/id/Make-a-nice-swimming-oil-lamp-out-of-nearly-noth/
posted May 2, 2008 - 10:33 pm by Carey
A comment on GMO. Do you enjoy beefsteak tomatoes, peaches n cream corn, how bout granny smith apples??? All GMO at one point. We have the varieties of food we have because of GMO. Im not saying I agree with it, but how bout 'everything in moderation'. I had a client the other day trying some of my homemade body lotion to which I added 1(one!) drop of colour for a batch of 16 -8oz bottles, I thought she was going to fall out of her chair. C'mon.
posted May 30, 2008 - 10:49 am by Jane
I admit up front that I'm biased, but from what I've found, even soy candles are not a healthy alternative. As Suzanne noted, most soy grown in North America is genetically modified. Soy candles are made from hydrogenated soybean oil that is heated to a high temperature and introduced to hydrogen and nickel (a suspected carcinogen) as a catalyst to solidify the oil. Synthetic colours and scents are usually added that produce toxic fumes when burned. I experimented making soy candles until I learned this.

Also, essential oils lose their therapeutic value when exposed to high heat.

I make pure 100% beeswax candles with cotton wicks. They are good in every way. The only thing I've never been able to substantiate is the claims about negative ions -- I've searched but never found real scientific evidence. If anybody knows where to find that evidence, please let me know.
posted Jul 1, 2008 - 11:48 am by Fred
In all the years that I have been burning candles , beeswax candles are by far the cleanest burning
and nicest to burn. Cotton wicking is by far the best wicking for beeswax . As for the Phoney Bheylonians in Ontario don't believe their marketing hype. They use low grade brown wax and the natural fiber wicking gives off toxic fumes when it burns. There are a lot better quality and less expensive beeswax candles on the market.
posted Jul 11, 2008 - 7:38 pm by Jane
I've come upon this article and discussion rather late, but I'd like to add my two cents worth anyway.
Soy candles are not natural products. Soy is not a wax, therefore it must be processed (meaning chemicals!) to become a wax that can make candles. Also, the vast majority of soy candles have artificial fragrances added. As Sharon says above, you don't know where the soy is coming from and it's highly unlikely that most of us would be happy if we knew the source.
I admit to being biased in this as I make and sell pure beeswax candles. My wax comes from a beekeeper near me so I know its provinence. Beeswax is the only natural and sustainable material for making candles.

Jane of Smallbones
www.smallbones.ca
posted Jul 13, 2008 - 3:06 am by Amanda
I personally love beeswax candles and all the health benefits with them. My family has had a history of allergies, but when these have been burning (daily) everyone tends to feel a lot better than not. I have actually began to make my own now, and they do last a long time. Not a thing added to them. After researching the health benefits I got rid of any paraffin candles I had. I've even made birthday candles, so I don't need to purchase anymore of the paraffin.
Add your comment
Name
Email AddressURL (Optional)
Comment
Free Newsletter & Digital Magazine
Enter Your Email Address:
Digital Magazine:Get your free digital copy of Green Living Magazine in your inbox, four times a year.
Green Living Newsletter:Green tips & feature stories in your inbox, once a week.
The DeLish Bite »
Lindsay Evans blogs about food, entertaining and her favourite recipes for Green Living.
Canadian wines from the Niagara Region

Sustainable Beauty »
Learn how to green your fashion, cosmetics and personal care products with Erin Schrode
The Discerning Spa visitor: part one

Green at a glance »
Stay up to date with everything happening that’s green.
Strange market fluctuations